John Schoonbee – Why the reinsurance industry believes type 2 diabetes is reversible — and what that means for food

Four or five eggs, swimming in butter. For breakfast!

That is how Dr. John Schoonbee eats. A trained doctor and Global Chief Medical Officer at Swiss Re (a $43 billion reinsurance giant), John studied medicine in South Africa and worked as a GP before following his love of maths into reinsurance. His job is to spot the health trends that shape how long people live; and for the past decade, one trend in particular has caught his attention: nutrition.

It’s a breakfast that goes against almost everything many of us have been taught about healthy eating. But John’s blood work is perfect, and he argues that our fear of fat may be one of the great misconceptions of modern nutrition — what he calls “probably the most successful brainwashing exercise ever.” John’s case is that type 2 diabetes, long taught as chronic and progressive, can be put into remission through more nutrient-dense food, fewer carbohydrates and more fat. And because healthier policyholders live longer, a reinsurer has a very concrete reason to care.

In this episode, we get into the fear of fat, why diets fail, and what John has learned from the evidence around nutrient dense food and low-carb, higher-fat diets.

WHAT DOCTORS AREN’T TAUGHT

Most doctors get a mere couple of hours of nutrition training, largely copied from the official guidelines. John’s view changed thanks to a former lecturer who did something few scientists ever do: publicly admit he got it wrong. Then, around 2015, John started seeing doctors around the world achieve something most textbooks said was impossible: putting type 2 diabetics into remission.

“For a number of years I’ve been looking at nutrition because I think it’s one of the most underutilised and misunderstood aspects of health, and particularly its role when it comes to metabolic health or metabolic ill health.” — John Schoonbee

WHY A REINSURER CARES ABOUT YOUR HEALTH

What does a $43 billion reinsurer gain when its policyholders eat differently? We dive into the business case behind Swiss Re’s nutrition pilots in the US, and why John’s colleagues once thought he’d lost it for bringing nutrition up at all. He makes the case that healthier policyholders are a win-win: they pay premiums for longer, which in turn means insurers can charge less for cover, so more people can afford it.

“I always joke that the insurance industry is the healthiest in the world.” — John Schoonbee

FAT IS BAD: THE MOST SUCCESSFUL BRAINWASHING STRATEGY

For decades, the whole world has been taught the same message: FAT IS BAD. But, could it be one of the most successful brainwashing strategies that has ever existed? The fear of fat goes back to the diet-heart hypothesis the half-century-old idea that eating fat raises cholesterol and causes heart disease. Yet large studies have found that more fat, even saturated fat, doesn’t increase heart disease risk, and on a higher-fat, lower-carb diet, markers like blood pressure, triglycerides and blood sugar improve. So why is the medical world, and cardiologists in particular, still so attached to it?

“I think the thing that’s gonna help the metabolically sick people, which is the majority of adults, is to remove the fear of fat.” — John Schoonbee

WE MADE DIABETES WORSE

What has the fear of fat cost us? In the 1950s, around 1% of Americans had diabetes. Today it’s close to 17%. Because diabetics are at higher risk of heart disease, they were told to cut fat, which meant eating more carbs. Could it be that we have made diabetes worse for the last 30 or 40 years? And how do we fix it with food?

“You could ask a child this: if glucose is spiking and that’s causing insulin to spike and that’s causing insulin resistance, what should we do? How do we solve this?” — John Schoonbee

“The intervention, or the fix for these people, was nutrition. That’s what it was. It was changing what they ate. And then what became more interesting was they were eating essentially the opposite of what a lot of guidelines would be telling these people to eat.” — John Schoonbee

WHAT DOES THIS MEAN FOR THE FOOD SYSTEM?

Does low carb mean carnivore? Is all processed food bad? Should we focus on quality or quantity first? Better health at scale will take more than asking people to change what they eat. Access, affordability and what’s on supermarket shelves matter too. We can’t treat all ultra-processed food as equal, and John sees a real opportunity for food companies, and the investors behind them, to make everyday food metabolically healthier. And if we’re all going to eat more fat, how do we produce it at scale?

“We don’t want this to be the realm of the well to do. We want everybody to be able to do this.” — John Schoonbee

OTHER POINTS DISCUSSED

Koen and John also discussed:

  • Eating nutrient dense food that doesn’t spike your blood glucose: how this simple advice from Dr David Unwin, a GP in Southport, UK, helps half of the type 2 diabetics who take it up into remission, backed by handouts with sugar equivalent charts, and the story of Chris, who went from 125 kg and barely able to walk 500 metres at 39 to running half marathons at 64
  • Avoid Sugar, not fat: why John calls sugar “extremely harmful”, pointing to the work of US endocrinologist Robert Lustig, and why many pre-diabetics could return to a normal glucose range simply by cutting sugar and using the kind of techniques the Glucose Goddess shares, from eating carbs last to cooking, cooling and reheating them
  • Guidelines built on a hypothesis: how going back to the evidence behind demonising fat showed John there never really was any, leading him to conclude that “we basically got the whole world to eat in a certain way based on our hypothesis”, one that has still never been tested in a proper randomised controlled trial

LINKS:

  • The Lore of Running: Book by Tim Noakes
  • The Carbohydrate-insulin Model: A Physiological Perspective on the Obesity Pandemic: Research paper by David S Ludwig et. al
  • Type 2 Diabetes Reversal: Presentation at Food For Thought Virtual Conference 
  • KETO: The 4 letter word in nutrition: Article by John Schoonbee 

MORE INTERVIEWS IN THIS SERIES:


——————————————

Feedback, comments, suggestions? Reach me via Twitter @KoenvanSeijen, in the comments below or through Get in Touch on this website.

Join the Investing in Regenerative Agriculture and Food newsletter on www.eepurl.com/cxU33P

The above references an opinion and is for information and educational purposes only. It is not intended to be investment advice. Seek a duly licensed professional for investment advice.

2 comments on “John Schoonbee – Why the reinsurance industry believes type 2 diabetes is reversible — and what that means for food”

  1. Kalpna says:

    Hi,
    I enjoyed reading about John Schoonbee and the importance of regenerative agriculture. I also use this resource to compare medical weight-loss programmes and explore available options https://rolandmedicalweightloss.com/comparison/compare-roland-medical-weight-loss-programs/

    1. Antonella says:

      thank you for sharing Kalpna.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *